Does challenging superstition or faith protect people?
Is it mistaken to support organised religion in membership or donations?
If people do good because they are human, not because God prompts them,
is it right to risk giving God any credit when they alone own their good?




Telegraph 1880 Sheds Light on the Dubious Apparition of Knock

1880 report on the happenings by an expert indicates lying

Patrick Beirne witness to the vague image at Knock

How reliable was Archdeacon Cavanagh during the Knock shrine origin?

Was the Archdeacon behind a pious fraud at Knock?

Knock Apparition - how high was it on the gable?

Knock - were the Witnesses Colluding to concoct a miracle tale??

Knock Fraud - Was the Parish Priest Involved?

Problems with the first commission of enquiry at Knock

Projector fits the Knock data concerning the alleged apparition

Knock - Sceptic Priest Herbert Thurston

Knock - is it true that the vision was seen before it got dark as well as after?

Knock: Patrick Beirne gives the evidence that the vision was not amazing

Knock - Questions that entice us to suspect fraud

Knock Spurious Apparition of Mary and two saints

Knock the Hoax?

Knock - the differences and omissions between original witness accounts

Knock - clues in original witness accounts that it was a natural event not a miracle

Knock Commission was incapable of investigation or professionalism

Knock - was the apparition a painting?

Knock - Meaning of the Apparition

Knock - who was the bishop that appeared?

Knock - Miracle Hoax about the Dry Gable

Knock Apparition - Statues Put at Gable by Hoaxer?

Knock Apparition - a trick of the light?

Knock Apparition - from The Story of Ireland 1900

Knock Witnesses - Their Depositions under the Spotlight

Knock Vision - evidence that a hoaxer used a projector/magic lantern

Knock witnesses copied the vision story from other sources

Knock - Patrick Walsh did not see the magic light from a distance

Knock - The Bad Fruits

Knock's Dubious Cures

Knock in the Light of David Hume's scepticism of miracles

Knock - recent apparition claims

Knock - where the witnesses stood shows apparition claims spurious

Letter from priest that reduces credibility of Knock apparition

Case for a clear vision at Knock in 1879

Vague apparitions like Knock always get their quality exaggerated

Was it drink that started the Knock apparition fuss?